Monday 31 March 2014

Not Over Yet

Even at this late stage there are probably a number of Napo members undecided as to whether to strike or not. Whether to support their colleagues and deliver on the notion of collective responsibility. Some will feel that 'it's all over' and there's no point. Well I think it might be worth reading what Harry Fletcher has to say in his latest blog post published yesterday. 

Napo has been very fortunate indeed in having been able to secure the part-time services of the former Assistant General Secretary and as he makes clear, there is still considerable mileage in the Parliamentary process. In the circumstances, I'm sure there can't be any truth in the rumour that the union is considering early termination of his temporary employment, can there? This is what he has to say:-
Pace of Sell Off
The All Party Justice Committee became the latest group on March 25th to express concern at the pace of the Transforming Rehabilitation agenda. MPs demanded clarification of the exact date of the take over of the new providers of supervision. Was it Autumn 2014 or spring 2015? They also asked whether or not the unions had signed off a post sale package and by implication the sale itself. The unions remain as ever 100% opposed to the sale. Problems continue to emerge most days with the timetable. 
The faster the pace the more likely the chance of errors. Over the last few days staff have learnt - that MAPPA eligible's were not included in the caseload calculation (and there are about 10,000 in that group), glitches occurred in staff accessing the Risk of Serious Recidivism tool, the main IT system is not suitable for AT users, report writing will take longer and there are insufficient staff to maintain the flow of reports to the courts anyway. 
The full implications for TR of Buddi pulling out of the £300 million tagging contract for hardware are becoming apparent: a) the timetable for the huge increase in tagging is behind what was hoped b) it is another example of a contract being let in an over hasty way c) bidders may start to think that what they believe they are after and what they will get are rather different. The Coalition had hoped to have the new traditional tag plus GPS tracking in place by mid 2015 with an increase from the current numbers tagged on a given day rising fro 26,000 now to at least 75,000 by 2020.
Over 20 parliamentary Questions drafted on behalf of Napo by Harry Fletcher on court chaos and tagging have been tabled via Justice Union MPs. At least 15 members of Parliament have written to the MOJ about different aspects of TRs progress. Many more will follow.  
The Future 
The strategy for slowing and defeating TR remains unchanged. It is a combination of Parliamentary action, legal challenges and industrial action. Legal opinion is needed and sought over a number of issues; the validity of using the Offender Management Act 2007 to avoid legislation, risk registers, the timetable and risk to the public, consultation with staff over transfer and allocation and the test of recklessness.
In Parliament questions both written and oral will continue, debates will be requested, points of order will be raised, EDMs will be placed and lobbying must continue. During the next 6 months all Probation staff should be sending to a central point details of their observations and experiences. They must then be published both in Parliament and the media.
PS - on twitter Harry poses this key question:- 

Question for MOJ How many of the original 50 bidders are not proceeding to the next stage and why have they dropped out?

Another blog always worth reading is that by Effie Perine and here is a taster:-
Rather than signalling the end, it’s the beginning of a new phase in which we can start to see our predictions become reality – and speaking personally, the more I find out and the more my team and I try to work out how we’re actually going to do this, the more holes and problems we can see. But now they’re becoming more than anecdote. They’re going to have a real, measurable impact in the real world.
Yes, it’s going to be hard. It’s going to be awful, and we’re going to have so much more pressure put on us. But we can use this. This is the time when the wheels really start to come off. I think it’s important that this phase in the project is going to be marked with the industrial action Monday and Tuesday – a reminder that WE are all in this together, solid ground we can fight from in this sea of uncertainty.
Napo wants to hear from members on this, as per the link to Jim’s post above. I think we also need to hear from our friends across the justice system. If you notice changes in probation, if problems come up that are potentially linked to the new system, please help us by talking to us about it. Talk to officers in court, your local Napo branch, or contact campaigns@napo.org.uk. Talk to us on twitter or blogs, and we can pass your information on, maybe enlighten you a bit more abut the reasons for problems too. Let’s keep talking, keep working together.
On that note, I look forward to seeing plenty of you on Tuesday at the Justice Alliance demo – meet 2:15pm, Old Palace Yard, opposite Parliament. There’s a rally in Cardiff April 1st, 12:30pm, at the Aneurin Bevan monument on Queen Street, and plenty of other local events across England and Wales. Check your local Napo branch’s twitter feed for information, or www.napo.org.uk. Picketing will be taking place at probation offices and courts from 12 noon on Monday 31st.
The full blog post 'The Plural of Anecdote' can be found here and is well worth reading. Finally, I saw this on the Napo Forum and rather liked it's simplicity:-


Image

12 comments:

  1. http://www.theguardian.com/law/2014/mar/31/legal-aid-cuts-demonstrations-criminal-justice

    Criminal solicitors and probation officers begin 48 hours of industrial action on Monday in protest at cuts to legal aid and the privatising of offender rehabilitation services.

    The combined demonstration against Ministry of Justice policies is aimed at bringing the criminal justice system in magistrates and crown courts across England and Wales to a standstill.

    Despite criminal barristers settling their differences with the justice secretary, Chris Grayling, last week, solicitors who conduct criminal defence and prosecution work are persevering with their mass walkout.

    These protest are the third time this year that lawyers have taken direct action over MoJ plans to slice £215m out of the department's annual budget for legal aid. The Justice Alliance - a coalition of charities, unions and community groups that including Liberty, Unite, The Howard League for Penal Reform and Coram Children's Legal Centre - is supporting the demonstrations.

    It warns that imminent changes to judicial review will also have a chilling effect on challenging poor government decision-making, leading to a situation of state impunity.

    Probation officers planned their strike some time ago. They will not start their walkout until midday on Monday. Ian Lawrence, general secretary of NAPO, the national association of probation officers, said: "The government plan to outsource 70% of the probation service is untried and untested.

    "It is a dangerous social experiment that we believe will lead to a reduction in rehabilitation and fragment risk management, placing the public at risk. These reforms are ideologically driven and being pushed by a political timetable."

    Nicola Hill, president of the London Criminal Courts Solicitors Association said: "What is happening to probation and criminal legal aid belongs to the same sorry story. That's why criminal defence solicitors are standing by colleagues in probation.

    "As the government dismantles the criminal justice system, risks are being taken which threaten public safety and the right to a fair defence. The MOJ is taking a gamble on outsourcing the supervision of the most persistent offenders on release from short-term prison sentences.

    "Meanwhile as the justice secretary scrimps on legal aid, the risk of the innocent going to jail is set to become a nightmarish reality. Miscarriages of justice for ordinary people will increase because they can't get a decent lawyer."

    ReplyDelete
  2. Some barristers threatened to support the action despite the deal reached last week. Henry Blaxland QC said: "I and other barristers support the protests on the 1 April.

    "The Criminal Bar Association ignored calls by many of its members for support for the solicitors' and probation officers' days of action and, instead, did a deal with Grayling, without consulting the membership. We shall continue to unite for justice and together will fight to oppose cuts to legal aid."

    Matt Foot of the Justice Alliance says: "This is the first time in history when solicitors, barristers and probation officers have taken joint action not to work the courts. All but the rich will suffer because of these cuts - which is why we are united and determined to stop [Grayling]."

    Demonstrations are expected outside courts. The largest on Monday will be outside Westminister Magistrates court. On Tuesday 1 April - which is also the Justice Secretary's birthday - a rally will be held outside parliament followed by a march on the Ministry of Justice.

    The MoJ maintains that the UK's legal aid budget is about £2bn a year, making it "one of the most expensive legal aid systems in the world", and insists it will "remain very generous even after reform".

    Grayling said last month: "This government is dealing with an unprecedented financial challenge and I have no choice but to look for the savings ... I cannot exempt legal aid but that doesn't mean I don't understand how challenging these reductions will be. The final package does mean fee reductions, but it also includes a series of measures to ease their effect on lawyers."

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good luck today with the strike
    Fight for what is right

    ReplyDelete
  4. Could people publicise where the rallies and meetings will take place please. With so many reading the blog I am sure we can pick up some supporters at these key events.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Can't resist flagging this up.

    http://www.politics.co.uk/news/2014/03/31/happy-birthday-justice-secretary-campaigners-prepare-book-pr

    ReplyDelete
  6. Chris Grayling is set to be given dozens of books for his birthday tomorrow, as campaigners try to embarrass him over the prisoner book ban.

    Writers at Liberty will deliver a large parcel of books to the justice secretary, as they gather outside his department to read out poems in protest at the policy.

    "Toxic spin on human rights, savage attacks to our justice system and now the lord chancellor bans books from prisons," Shami Chakrabarti, Liberty director, said.

    "These policies underestimate the underlying decency of the British electorate and this bonfire of books and liberties looks less like an April Fool than pure spite."

    Liberty staff are expected to arrive with a large box of books with a large bow and a giant gift tag addressed to: "Inmates of HMP, c/o Justice Secretary Chris Grayling from all at Liberty."

    The stunt comes on what promises to be a birthday to forget for the justice secretary, who will also have to endure a protest outside parliament by probation staff and solicitors, who are on a joint strike action over legal aid cuts and privatisation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. On this point - I see that the Howard League have announced a judicial review on the book ban, a week after Frances Crook's original tweet sparked the whole issue off. I do accept that Napo is in a different position, but surely our own legal challenge to TR could have come sooner?

      Delete
    2. Much, much, much sooner!

      Delete
  7. Manchester rally tomorrow at 1pm

    ReplyDelete
  8. Crown Square Manchester 1 o'clock tomorrow

    ReplyDelete
  9. I was out today for what I believe in, but it may well put me in bankruptcy!
    What about the social discrimination in this society, which will never be addressed by payment by results! What will be a result could be manipulated in terms of the moving goal posts of privateers.
    I am currently taking over very high risk cases without proper transfer arrangements whilst still dealing with high risk offenders who take up an enormous amount of time to manage. Very little management input.
    The stress is building and I can foresee an SFO looming. Too little time, too little thought, too little management possible for these very risky individuals,............................Spock get me out of here!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anon at 17.50.

      Thanks for taking action for wider probation - I hope you now take action via Union and your management to protect yourself - there has been much about it in recent weeks, including submitting accident/incident reports in appropriate situations - I guess procedures vary but if advice is not available via own branch contacts get in touch with Napo HQ - that is what you pay your subs for.

      Delete