Thursday 30 June 2011

The Unwelcome Guest?

When asked what I do for a living, on more than one occasion I've joked about earning my living from crime. Of course although in a sense it's literally true for many of us in the police, prison, court and probation services, not to mention the legal profession, it never was a funny joke. Even less so now that some of us will inevitably find ourselves doing something else next year when the cuts really start to bite.

I guess all of us in the criminal justice system have always had that thought lurking at the back of our mind that if we were really successful at what we were doing, we wouldn't have a job. We never give it much thought though as clearly nothing much seems to work and hence up till now there's never been a real danger that the mortgage wouldn't get paid. It doesn't stop us trying to be more effective of course and many a career has been built on introducing new initiatives, or just plain old re-inventing the wheel, depending on your view and place on the career ladder. 

Following on from casework theory, in recent times we have embraced the 'What Works' agenda, explored all the accredited programme routes via cognitive behavioural therapy and are currently discovering desistance theory and engagement strategies. Oh, whilst restoring a degree of autonomy and discretion to officers in how they supervise cases. It's been quite a party, but suddenly we seem to have a cheeky uninvited and possibly unwelcome guest. 

Mark Johnson, an ex-offender and former drug user is a regular contributor to The Guardian and recently officially launched his charity User Voice

Their Mission statement says:-

"Only offenders can stop re-offending. User Voice's mission is to engage those who have experience of the criminal justice system in bringing about its reform and to reduce offending.

User Voice is a charity led and delivered by ex-offenders. This gives us the unique ability to gain the trust of, access to and insight from people within the criminal justice system." 

Whilst many probation trusts have recently been pondering the whole issue of 'engagement' and how that might be achieved, Mark has some forthright views on the subject and some may feel they don't make for particularly comfortable reading. Although the Guardian article was mainly aimed at the prison service, I think the sentiment extends far wider.

"Anyone who thinks that the inevitable cuts that lie ahead mean the criminal justice system can carry on doing things the same old way is kidding themselves. We have to recognise that we're chucking too much money at interventions that don't deliver. They've been carefully crafted, and with the best of intentions, by the educated for people whom they can't begin to understand. The only way to stop wasting money is to engage, and I'm talking about real engagement, not superficial consultation, with the frontline users of services.

Participation at this level cannot be led by people who design or implement interventions. They should not create an agenda, nor can they attempt truly receptive dialogue, with the offenders who take part in their interventions. There is only one way to deep trawl for the truth, and that is by allowing offenders their own forums, facilitated by peers, many of whom will be ex-offenders. Anything else is consultation.

Engagement will save a fortune in the long run but doing it right is not a cheap option. It costs. We're talking partnerships, contracts and proper pay structures for respected work. My organisation is 90% staffed by ex-offenders and I believe one indicator of true engagement is the number of ex-offenders on the payroll (another is how high up the internal ladder they are allowed to climb)."

He goes on:-

"That's what scares some service providers. The provider who has devised, nursed and implemented an intervention for offenders seldom welcomes the offenders' scrutiny and honest appraisal. The provider wants the intervention to work, and he can usually manipulate figures to convince himself it does. It's hard for him to hear the voice of the offender saying it hasn't helped and should be modified or abandoned. At worst, such scrutiny could put the provider out of a job. He'll try to defend his intervention no matter how redundant it is. Only the bravest want people like us coming inside the jail or community and promising to deliver the truth.

We'll always remain the unwelcome guest at the criminal justice party. We stand for true engagement, we offer a scientific level of scrutiny, we're asking for power, we want to be paid for the work we do. And we believe that our participation in the process of government is the key to a lower crime rate and a more economic prison service. It will take years. But now we've launched, we're on our way."

It's funny but this got me thinking of the good old days again when we had a very active volunteer group and a flourishing day centre. I well remember the fascinating but interminable discussions in team meetings about how much control or supervision was needed. Some of us got really excited about the active involvement of clients and how it could only be beneficial; how we should just let things develop organically; how it would be great if clients could progress to become accredited volunteers themselves.

But that was all rather too much for management at the time as sadly the Service was already moving inexorably towards one of command and control from the top. Well you know what they say - things go in circles eventually - you've just got to wait long enough.  

13 comments:

  1. I have got a question related to probation guidelines and procedures.....My boyfriend is on probation and is just finishing up with treatment. About a week ago, my ex boyfriend (at least that's who we think it is) started calling the treatment facility and his probation officer saying that he was not complying and was hanging out in areas he shouldn't be, etc. Even though my boyfriend is doing everything to comply, now the red flags are suddenly up and he is being called in all the time and we can no longer take our planned trip for the summer. They won't say who the caller is, and I am a little taken back to see how serious they are taking this. Is there anything we can do to stop the harassment and find out who is calling? At some point can we count on his probation officer to put his foot down with these calls?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm intrigued to know how you know about these calls? My only suggestion is an open and honest conversation between you both and the officer concerned. Hope things work out ok for you both.

      Cheers,

      Jim

      Delete
  2. Hello I am just wondering if you can meet the probation officer..my finance in side now..but is getting very confused with what they want and I wonder if I can talk to them then explain it to him..

    ReplyDelete
  3. So my dad is on probation in Texas for pill charges, well he moved to a different state without letting his probation officer know, I'm worried that he will get arrested, should I be?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am supposed to meet my probation officer for the first time on November 7th. It's November 6th. I am currently stuck in another city until November 8th. How do I handle this if I don't have my probation officers number?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Only saw this by chance - it's a very old blog post. I suggest you make contact with probation in the city where you are and see if they will help you.

      Delete
    2. Ok thank you.

      Delete
  5. I don't know if your still on here, but my name is Jessica I'm a 22year old female on probation and have a few questions for you. Is there anyway I can email you? My phone is a little slow and it's easier to email! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  6. In Georgia if someone is on probation and pulled over several times resulting in nothing being found can a different po and police show up at your house without your assigned po knowledge and search your home just because they don't like you.your assigned po didn't no of the search being conducted and you be arrested

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi my son breach an was on remand been their for 4 months now hopefully he may be out soon but the probation people not like him an are making him go in a hostel miles away from his family and friends what we dont get is why when he got a nice loving home an xmas as well just don't get it just want him home but not sure what to do

    ReplyDelete
  8. I want to write a letter on behalf of a person in jail however, I'm hesitant because I'm on probation myself. will writing a letter while on probation cause me any problems?

    ReplyDelete
  9. When my son went to court and was placed on probation his attorney didn't mention he was mentally disabled and have been since 7th grade deemed by the state of florida and has been on ssi/ssa since so they stipulated in his probation to work so he can pay his fines but he disabled but fines are getting paid by the both of us but how do i let the court know he's on ssi/ssa so they are not looking for him to hold employment?

    ReplyDelete
  10. To Jim Brown, all these people hear have legitimate issues with there probation and all you can say as a member of that community is in vague terms "that is terrible, hope it works out" or "I don't have enough details" maybe you should just delete your blog because it seems the anonymous comment makers have better advise to give to the people in need and that only seems to be due to the fact that they have either been through or are currently experiencing the BS of your profession.
    To anyone seeking answers don't come here. Jim in all of his higher learning and training can't seem to realize that he can't help anyone here because he himself has never had this issue in his life. in my opinion Jim needs to theoretical pull his head out of his rectum and open his eyes. He can't help these people and he is not aware of the issues in his own profession. just another fool who is "trying to help" but can't.

    ReplyDelete